This is a cache of https://news.slashdot.org/story/24/10/31/2030255/us-army-should-ditch-tanks-for-ai-drones-says-eric-schmidt. It is a snapshot of the page at 2024-11-01T01:14:51.430+0000.
US Army Should Ditch Tanks For AI Drones, Says Eric Schmidt - Slashdot

Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
AI The Military United States

US Army Should Ditch Tanks For AI Drones, Says Eric Schmidt (theregister.com) 5

Former Google chief Eric Schmidt thinks the US Army should expunge "useless" tanks and replace them with AI-powered drones instead. From a report: Speaking at the Future Investment Initiative in Saudi Arabia this week, he said: "I read somewhere that the US had thousands and thousands of tanks stored somewhere," adding, "Give them away. Buy a drone instead."

The former Google supremo's argument is that recent conflicts, such as the war in Ukraine, have demonstrated how "a $5,000 drone can destroy a $5 million tank." In fact, even cheaper drones, similar to those commercially available for consumers, have been shown in footage on social media dropping grenades through the open turret hatch of tanks. Schmidt, who was CEO of Google from 2001 to 2011, then executive chairman to 2015, and executive chairman of Alphabet to 2018, founded White Stork with the aim of supporting Ukraine's war effort. It hopes to achieve this by developing a low-cost drone that can use AI to acquire its target rather than being guided by an operator and can function in environments where GPS jamming is in operation.

Notably, Schmidt also served as chair of the US government's National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence (NSCAI), which advised the President and Congress about national security and defense issues with regard to AI. "The cost of autonomy is falling so quickly that the drone war, which is the future of conflict, will get rid of eventually tanks, artillery, mortars," Schmidt predicted.

US Army Should Ditch Tanks For AI Drones, Says Eric Schmidt

Comments Filter:
  • by JoshuaZ ( 1134087 ) on Thursday October 31, 2024 @08:53PM (#64910541) Homepage
    The tank being obsolete has been predicted on and off for 100 years no. Soon after they were introduced in World War I, people thought that new defensive setups would stop them from being used. In World War II, the bazooka and similar weapons people thought might make the tank obsolete. Then after World War II, those weapons became improved into the RPG-7 and similar. Then early in the current Russian invasion of Ukraine, even before the very major drone use, some people claimed that the Javelin had rendered tanks obsolete. And now drones. But in all these times, tanks have died to weapons because tanks are still being used because they make sense to use. Both Russia and Ukraine are losing ranks, but they both need to keep using tanks to secure objectives. The idea that drones will replace tanks just doesn't fit with what we are seeing right now.
    • In theory, an airplane should have made tanks obsolete. They can shoot the tank, and the tank can't shoot back. They do everything a drone can do.

      A tank will protect you from basically every weapon not specifically intended to stop tanks. Small arms fire, stray artillery, anti-personnel mines. Would you rather cross a mine field in a tank or on foot? Moving forward means tanks. In practice it turns out you need boots on the ground if you want to control territory, and tanks are extremely helpful when it'
  • Always blows my mind the platform we give people that were good at one random thing but feel the need to tell the armed forces how to do their job. Maybe the tech weenies should a. Do some research and b. Join the military and get qualified. Simplistic assumptions like this are irksome.
    • What's more stunning is that they think they know what the hell they're talking about it. The platform is unearned, but the arrogance and ignorance of their ignorance is on the likes of Schmidt, Musk, et al. Extreme wealth seems toxic to the human mind, replacing curiosity and creativity with hubris.

If computers take over (which seems to be their natural tendency), it will serve us right. -- Alistair Cooke

Working...